Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Evening Journal
Editorial May 26, 1903 Event 1 of 2

Evening Journal

Wilmington, New Castle County, Delaware

What is this article about?

This editorial compilation features two pieces: one from the Kansas City Star advocating for revised extradition treaties to prevent criminals from evading justice abroad, citing cases like Wainwright, Gaynor, Greene, Gillette, and Tweed; the second from the Indianapolis News discusses the inevitable displacement of weaker races by advancing civilizations through settlement, as in South America and Manchuria.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

This is Event 1 of 2. The full text below covers all events in this component.

EDITORIAL OPINION

Extradition Treaties.
From the Kansas City Star.

The announcement that the State Department cannot ask for the extradition of Ellis Wainwright, charged with bribery in St. Louis, emphasizes the need of a revision and extension of the extradition treaties. It is contrary to good morals and to common sense that a civilized country like France should harbor criminals because the treaty fails to mention bribery as an extraditable offense. The recent cases of Gaynor and Greene in Canada and Gillette in Mexico are still fresh in the public mind. It is remembered, too, that Boss Tweed was secured from Spain only as a matter of courtesy, since at that time the United States had no extradition treaty with Spain.

When notorious criminals can find shelter from the law on the continents of America and Europe it is evident that extradition conventions must still be in an undeveloped and primitive condition. It ought to be impossible for fugitives to live openly in Christendom with this stage of the world's progress. Judicial procedure against them after they have been caught is not so harsh as to warrant protecting them from trial. Under the existing treaties there are altogether too many ways of escape. The United States has never favored refusing asylum to political refugees. But that is no reason why common criminals should be allowed to go scot free, provided they have not committed one of the limited number of crimes mentioned in the present treaties.

The conventions need overhauling for the better protection of society.

Protecting the Weak Races.
From the Indianapolis News.

The lot of the inferior and unprogressive races is hard, but there is no way of protecting them against the march of civilization except when strong powers differ as to the disposition of the land occupied by them. For instance, we can keep European political systems out of South America, but we cannot—or at any rate we have not tried—to keep Europeans from settling in South American countries. And if large numbers of Germans and Englishmen were to make their homes in Venezuela, for example, the country would become German and English, even though there were not a German or English soldier within the country. It will be so in Manchuria. The land will be conquered without the help of soldiers, and no power or combination of powers can prevent it.

What sub-type of article is it?

Foreign Affairs Legal Reform

What keywords are associated?

Extradition Treaties Criminal Fugitives Treaty Revision Bribery Offense International Asylum

What entities or persons were involved?

Ellis Wainwright Gaynor Greene Gillette Boss Tweed State Department France Canada Mexico Spain

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Revision Of Extradition Treaties

Stance / Tone

Advocacy For Stronger International Extradition

Key Figures

Ellis Wainwright Gaynor Greene Gillette Boss Tweed State Department France Canada Mexico Spain

Key Arguments

State Department Cannot Extradite Wainwright Due To Treaty Omission Of Bribery France Harbors Criminals Because Bribery Not Extraditable Cases Like Gaynor/Greene In Canada, Gillette In Mexico Highlight Treaty Flaws Tweed Extradited From Spain Only By Courtesy, No Treaty Then Criminals Find Shelter In America And Europe Due To Primitive Treaties Fugitives Should Not Live Openly In Modern Christendom Too Many Escape Routes Under Current Treaties Protect Political Refugees But Not Common Criminals

Are you sure?